WEDNESDAY DEC 25, 2024
×
Search AeroXplorer
Pilots Who Didn't Pay Attention Overshot Their Destination by Over 150 Miles: Northwest Airlines Flight 188

Pilots Who Didn't Pay Attention Overshot Their Destination by Over 150 Miles: Northwest Airlines Flight 188

BY JACK TURNER January 04, 2024 0 COMMENTS

On October 21, 2009, one of the strangest aviation incidents occurred. A regularly scheduled Airbus A320 flight on Northwest Airlines Flight 188 landed over one hour late at Minneapolis-St. Paul (MSP), after flying from San Diego. However, the delay was not caused by a mechanical problem or weather. The plane landed late simply because the pilots forgot to land the plane. 

 

The Airbus A320 involved in the incident, pictured at Ronald Reagan Washington National Airport (DCA) in 2005 | Photo: Flickr

 

The pilots completely phased out during the flight and overshot the Minneapolis area by 150 nautical miles. Though the aircraft landed safely in Minneapolis and taxied normally to a gate with no injuries involved to passengers, the situation could have been far worse. 

 



ADVERTISEMENT • REMOVE ALL ADS

 

Around two hours into the flight, as the aircraft passed through Denver, Colorado, it lost contact with Denver Air Traffic Control (ATC). As a response, Denver ATC tried to get the plane to gain contact with Minneapolis ATC but failed. Even texts from Northwest and alerts from other aircraft were unsuccessful at regaining contact with the plane. The situation got so problematic that even the White House Situation Room officials were alerted. 

 

A Northwest Airlines Boeing 747-400 at Kansai International Airport (KIX) in Osaka, Japan in 1999 | Photo: Flickr

 

Just as fighter jets were mobilizing to check on the plane's status, Minneapolis ATC regained contact with the plane, although, by that point, the aircraft was over 100 miles east of the airport in Eau Claire, Wisconsin. At that point, the pilots were in full contact with ATC and returned to Minneapolis to land, but not after having to fly in ATC-instructed patterns to confirm that the pilots had control of the aircraft. 

 

Surprisingly, the pilots told investigators they were not asleep at the yoke but had been reviewing schedules on their laptops. Still, reviewing schedules on laptops is a serious breach of airline policy and resulted in the pilots' grounding on October 27, 2009. The pilots also reported not hearing any alerts or messages in the cockpit outside of Captain Timothy Cheney hearing "chatter" on the radio, according to his interview with investigators. 

 

A Northwest Airlines Airbus A320 with different livery | Photo: Wikimedia Commons

 

A secondhand account of the situation by a friend of Captain Cheney states that the First Officer had, while Captain Cheney was in the bathroom, switched the frequency as instructed but had flubbed some numbers such that the aircraft was tuned to Winnipeg, Manitoba airspace where any communication between the center and the plane would be inaudible given the distance. 

 



ADVERTISEMENT • REMOVE ALL ADS

 

Other factors, such as the Airbus A320 not featuring advanced technology to use an audible chime to alert the crew of messages from the airline, contributed to a lack of situational awareness that was only resolved when flight attendants asked for an update on landing time at MSP. 

 

A Northwest Airlines Boeing 747 with different livery | Photo: Airliners.net

 

In the end, nobody was hurt in the incident, and to a degree, the incident is less serious than many might suspect. We cannot be 100% sure of the events that transpired, and indeed, not all of the conversation history from the cockpit of that flight is available to investigate. Still, the incident did prompt serious changes in the industry. Lawmakers moved to ban laptops in the cockpit, a policy some airlines have adopted, and additional automation procedures have been implemented. This type of incident, fortunately, has not occurred since. 

 



ADVERTISEMENT • REMOVE ALL ADS

 

 AeroXplorer is on Telegram! Subscribe to the AeroXplorer Telegram Channel to receive aviation news updates as soon as they are released. View Channel 
Jack Turner
Jack is a member of the AeroXplorer writing team and particularly enjoys sharing news around domestic flying and news surrounding his favorite airline, Delta. Jack splits his time between his hometown of Burlingame, California and Ithaca, New York and enjoys all things public transport in addition to aviation.

Comments (0)

Add Your Comment

SHARE

TAGS

STORIES Northwest Airlines Minneapolis/St. Paul MSP San Diego SAN Airbus A320 A320 Incident History Safety

RECENTLY PUBLISHED

PHOTOS: Azerbaijan Airlines E190 Crashes in Kazakhstan An Azerbaijan Airlines Embraer E190 crashed approximately 3 km from the city of Aktau today, December 25. Images from the scene show that the aircraft lost speed and then crashed, followed by a large explosion. NEWS READ MORE »
South African Airways Eyes India–South Africa Route As part of its recovery strategy, South African Airways (SAA) is exploring the reinstatement of direct flights between India and South Africa. SAA, along with Minister of Tourism Patricia de Lille, on December 3, 2024, participated in a high-level delegation to India to strengthen aviation and tourism ties between the two nations. ROUTES READ MORE »
Ethiopian Airlines Expands Fleet with Second Airbus A350-1000 Ethiopian Airlines, Ethiopia's national carrier, has taken delivery of its second Airbus A350-1000, registered as ET-BAX. This advanced aircraft is powered by Trent XWB-97 engines, further solidifying the airline’s commitment to modernizing its fleet. NEWS READ MORE »


SHOP

$2999
NEW!AeroXplorer Aviation Sweater Use code AVGEEK for 10% off! BUY NOW

FOLLOW US ONLINE